Society: privilege and duty

I was planning a post on colonisation this week to follow on from last week’s one on the Great Famine. But then a conversation at the weekend got me thinking about society instead. And our place within it.

What are our duties to society, as members of that group?

Now, I’m using society here as others would use “culture”, “land”, “people”, “tuath”. I mean the people we live with, the laws we (mostly) abide by, that sort of thing. What do we owe our communities? Our families? Ourselves?

A cartoon image of a bunch of people - loads of them, all different sizes, shapes and colours, trying to represent what society is. Or might be...
People make up society

Let’s define what we mean by society

As you were reading that list of things above you were probably thinking all these are alternatives to society, but don’t really tell me what the damn thing actually is, Orlagh. So cough up!

Dictionary.com comes to the rescue:

the aggregate of people living together in a more or less ordered community.

I mean, of course there are other meanings. It can also mean a group of people coming together because of a specific shared interest, or High Society, where we have defined a subgroup of people within a broader context.

But really, we use society when we’re talking about the people in an area. Sometimes as large as a whole continent, sometimes as small as a single street. It doesn’t really matter.

It’s the people that make up the group. And how those people behave make up the social norms for that group. So, as we go through the rest of this – and I’ll give you the context in the next section – remember, we’re talking about people. Sure, we’re going to mention organisations, groups, individuals, officials, all sorts. But they’re all people at their hearts.

(OK most of them are people – I have my doubts about some!)

The context

I was talking to a friend at the weekend about the experiences of women during investigations into sexual assaults (SA) and rape. And to start with, he was very much of the opinion that it was a woman’s duty to society report the rape and go through the investigation. Now, I vehemently disagree with this, but being the lovely person I am (and he’s a good person really, just hadn’t thought about the consequences of his line of thought) I kept on speaking with him on the topic.

I know – I’m a saint! (<– sarcasm)

We spoke about some of my experiences with various forms of SA. And how I didn’t report the vast majority of them and why. I explained how women have used “gossip” for generations to warn others of violence or misbehaviour, and why they couldn’t come public about any of it. I spoke of the many, many ways various religions and state organisations have made it so women are not safe to come forward about these things publicly.

But, he replied – that’s not modern Ireland. We’re different. Our society is different. We treat women better.

Are we though?

The following is a series of links to the SA and rape cases I remember in the last decade or so. Please don’t click the links if you’re not able to:

The Thong case.

The Belfast rugby case.

Meath rape case.

Kildare.

Let’s be clear – I could list at least one case from pretty much every county in Ireland. And the treatment of people is improving slightly, but it’s not there yet.

Women are equal in society, but their behaviour is more on trial than an accused rapist in these cases.

He changed his mind

I turned it around then and said I hope his daughters would never face that decision. That got him thinking. He started thinking of the individual women in the case then as people not just victims. He started thinking of the effect on his family, his daughters.

Now to be clear – this man is fairly well educated in these matters. He’s a feminist and walks the walk most of the time. But he has a few blind spots and this was one of them. We talked through what it means to be part of an investigation for SA or rape. We talked about the “rape kit“, re-traumatisation of victims – even with the best of intentions!

OK, we talked through a lot.

Or at least agreed to think about a woman’s “duty” to society in these cases. Because while I agree it’s ideal if a woman can report a SA and/or rape, there is a huge physical and mental toll to doing so.

Which brings me back to the original thought that prompted this post.

What do we owe the society in which we live?

Do we owe it our mental health?

Our privacy?

Our sexual history?

Careers?

Families?

Children?

Relationships?

Where do we draw the line?

What aboutery in our society

The worst part about this is that, it’s such a personal decision for everyone. Gisèle Pelicot took a very brave decision to waive her right to privacy to aid in the prosecution’s case (as far as I understand it. I may be wrong with regard to her reasons mind!) And then she had to go back to court to prove that while she had waived her right to privacy in that one regard, she had not waived it in general.

Now, Mme Pelicot is a class act in general. Her award from the second case has been donated to two charities, helping women. She is some woman, to say the least!

But hers was a relatively “straightforward” place. She was drugged and sold and raped without her knowledge.

What about the woman who has had a glass of wine?

Or who dressed in a way some might find sexy?

Or who – God forbid! – wore a lacy thong?

The whataboutery in our society when it comes to this sort of thing is horrendous. And when reporting crimes of this nature, we have to take into account the effect it will have on ourselves, our families and our society.

So what do we owe our society?

I don’t think we owe our society our privacy, our mental health, our history. What other crime demands so much exposure from the victim?

I said on Saturday I would never suggest to a woman to go to the Guards post-SA. And I defended my position. Because it can be immensely re-traumatising. It’s not something anyone should be forced into, or even have to be talked into. It should be something a victim arrives at by themselves.

I feel very strongly about this.

Now, I write and teach about Brig Ambue – the one who looks after the weak and helpless and less fortunate – literally the cowless. And looking through as many of the texts as I can stomach, the Brehon laws were big on reparative justice. Not confinement – that was for hostages, and even then… not always.

So, what do you think Brigid – in any of her guises – would say about the way we treat victims in this way? To be clear – the Brehon Laws were not brilliant in cases of SA with get-out-of-jail cards for if a woman was in a pub without her husband, or was in a populated place and didn’t call out…

Not perfect. But was it any better than what we force victims to do?

The Great Famine

The Great Famine. The Famine. An Gorta MĂłr. The Great Hunger. I’ve mentioned it before on the blog, but today, I want to delve a bit deeper. For those wanting a historical approach, I strongly recommend Finn Dwyers The Great Hunger series on his podcast, the Irish History Podcast. Over about 40 episodes, he really dives into the Famine, exploring the common narratives and a few things that we as a nation would prefer to brush over. (Yes, there is evidence of cannibalism for example. And yes, we did manage to fit in a rebellion even during the Famine years…)

As to why I’m choosing today to write about this? Well ok, I owe ye a blog post for this week and I’m a week behind for those who pay for the early access option! But also, because I’m being asked a lot from various people about why the Irish are so affected – even now, 180 years later – by stories from around the world on hunger, genocide, oppression…

A lot of people don’t understand the trauma that comes from an event like this in history. There are loads of authors writing about this from all sorts of perspectives – go onto Google Scholar and search for “Irish trauma famine”. Although, honestly, if you search hard enough, you’ll probably find someone, somewhere has written a paper and interpreted the evidence to suit your current views.

An image of the Great Famine memorial in Dublin. The Famine statues, in Custom House Quay in the Dublin Docklands, were presented to the City of Dublin in 1997.
The memorial for the Great Famine in Dublin

So let’s start with the facts

The Famine started with the failure of the potato crop in 1845. The failure of the potato crop meant anyone who was depending on the potato as their main source of food was screwed. It ended in 1852 (ish) despite the British government’s attempts to decree otherwise!

Now, to understand why this is, we need to get into absentee landlordism, colonialism, etc. Basically, Ireland at the time was part of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland, after being sold out by the Ascendency in 1800, with the Act of Union. The bastards. They all then decamped to Britain (not all, but absentee landlords were a fact of life in Ireland and the so-called middleman system.

Rent collection was left in the hands of the landlords’ agents, or middlemen. This assured the landlord of a regular income and relieved them of direct responsibility while leaving tenants open to exploitation by the middlemen. The ability of middlemen was measured by the rent income they could contrive to extract from tenants. Middlemen leased large tracts of land from the landlords on long leases with fixed rents and sublet to tenants, keeping any money raised in excess to the rent paid to the landlord. This system, coupled with minimal oversight of the middlemen, incentivised harsh exploitation of tenants. Middlemen would split a holding into smaller and smaller parcels so as to increase the amount of rent they could obtain.

– Great Famine (Ireland) – Wikipedia

Can you see some of the issues with this approach? Yeah?

Land doesn’t produce crops year after year after year, especially not the same crop, without failing in some nutrients or other. That’s a basic of crop rotation and leaving land fallow. But the Irish tenant didn’t have that luxury. And frankly – spuds were the only crop that could feed a family of 10+ on a quarter acre or less…

You throw in the fact that most of these families also had to labour on the landlord’s land as well, and didn’t get compensated for any improvements they made to the property, could be kicked off at a moment’s noticed (you think “employment at will is bad?) and well… it was a shitshow.

Just for context now, there were approx. 100,000 deaths due to the potato blight across the rest of Europe. Ireland lost 1,000,000+. (To famine. We lost another 1,000,000 to emigration)

But why?

Along with most families having to survive on spuds, most of them were surviving on a particular type of spud. One we don’t hear too much of anymore for some reason: The Irish Lumper. Perfect for growing in low nutrient, wet land. Perfect for Ireland, right?

But not when the majority of the population was depending on it for survival. The exact nature of the blight has been identified as Phytophthora infestans, which also affects tomatoes, apparently. Tomatoes were not a major food stuff in Ireland in the 1840’s. Just FYI.

The Irish Lumper though? That was the foodstuff of the poor. And a lot of Ireland was poor. The population had exploded in the 18th century, from approx 2,000,000 in the last years of the 17th century (so the 1690’s, when the Williamites and Jacobites were ravaging the country) to over 8,000,000 in the 1841 census (Finn Dwyer suggested in one of his episodes that was probably an underestimation as the census takers avoided some of the wilder and more remote parts of the country and so missed a fair few people)

So the land was under more and more strain. The people were under more and more strain. In previous famines, of which there were many, the ports closed to food stuffs. In this one?

Prime Minister Sir Robert Peel wrote to Sir James Graham in mid-October that he found the reports “very alarming”, but allayed his fears by claiming that there was “always a tendency to exaggeration in Irish news”.

– Great Famine (Ireland) – Wikipedia

The British government’s primary motive appears to be to not stifle private enterprise. Weirdly to modern ears, the Torys were slightly more effective than the Whigs. As one Charles Trevelyan said at the time:

We must not complain of what we really want to obtain. If small farmers go, and their landlords are reduced to sell portions of their estates to persons who will invest capital we shall at last arrive at something like a satisfactory settlement of the country.

And yes, that Trevelyan.

While there were elements in Britain that recognised this was wrong, the ruling parties and the Ascendency saw it as their rights to cleanse the countryside.

The phrase from John Mitchel’s The Last Conquest of Ireland (Perhaps), published in 1861, sums it up best, I think: “The Almighty, indeed, sent the potato blight, but the English created the Famine.”

The Great Famine – the basics

1845 – 1852

1,000,000 died

1,000,000 emigrated.

No, Ireland has not yet reached the levels of population from before the Famine.

Less than 25% of Irish (growing) soil was devoted to growing spuds. >75% were devoted to foodstuffs exported during the Famine.

In History Ireland magazine (1997, issue 5, pp. 32-36), Christine Kinealy, a Great Hunger scholar, lecturer and Drew University professor, relates her findings: “Almost 4,000 vessels carried food from Ireland to the ports of Bristol, Glasgow, Liverpool and London during 1847, when 400,000 Irish men, women and children died of starvation and related diseases. The food was shipped under military guard from the most famine-stricken parts of Ireland; Ballina, Ballyshannon, Bantry, Dingle, Killala, Kilrush, Limerick, Sligo, Tralee and Westport. A wide variety of commodities left Ireland during 1847, including peas, beans, onions, rabbits, salmon, oysters, herring, lard, honey, tongues, animal skins, rags, shoes, soap, glue and seed. The most shocking export figures concern butter. Butter was shipped in firkins, each one holding 9 gallons. In the first nine months of 1847, 56,557 firkins were exported from Ireland to Bristol, and 34,852 firkins were shipped to Liverpool. That works out to be 822,681 gallons of butter exported to England from Ireland during nine months of the worst year of the Famine.”

– Learn | Ireland’s Great Hunger Museum

Technically, this wasn’t genocide. The British government were not trying to murder the entire population. Just – slim it down a bit. (<– sarcasm there, people) After all, 8,000,000 is an awful amount of people taking up valuable land the Ascendency could be using to enrich themselves.

(Sorry, I keep trying to just give a list of facts here and it’s not possible)

Why isn’t the Great Famine genocide?

Mainly because the Brits weren’t trying to eliminate everyone of the Irish race from the face of the planet. That’s it. The fact they saw the elimination of the 25% of the population from the island as a good thing, is beside the point. They weren’t trying to kill us all.

It’s really that simple.

Plus – let’s face it – the British Empire have form in this regard. There were 12 famines in India during British Rule.(24 in Ireland during British rule, but to be fair it took them an extra 450 years or so to get to India) (Check out this list for loads more worldwide, not just British Empire)

It still doesn’t change the fact that had the ports been closed and the food that had been grown in Ireland, kept in Ireland, the Great Famine would have had far less of an impact on the nation.

Why am I writing about this now?

To explain the empathy and relationship the Irish feel with Palestinians. Honestly, most of us have no issue with Jews or with the fact that Israel exists.

But we have major issues with children, or indeed anyone, being shot trying to get food.

Major issues with people starving with food waiting for them a few miles away.

Massive issues with hospitals, schools and other public institutions being bombed.

That sort of thing strikes a chord in our hearts, because we recognise the Israeli tactics.

We recognise the punishment of an entire population for the actions of a few.

We know what a family member will do to get food and water for their tuath.

Collective punishment is something we got really familiar with during British occupation. The only reason the Brits didn’t cut off water and electricity in the North was because the communities were too intertwined. But where they could cut people off, they were known to do so. They didn’t give a shit about hungry children, starving babies.

To be clear – this is not an endorsement of the actions of Hamas on 7th October, 2023. That too was horrendous, horrible, grievous, painful attack that should never have happened. Babies, children, the elderly – no one was spared.

But the numbers don’t add up:

1200 Israeli causalities, 800 of them civilians

5000 people injured

240 hostages taken.

All of which is traumatic to a nation open to attack pretty much on all sides.

But there have been more than 50,000 Palestinians killed since then.

And I understand the deep need to have the remaining 50 hostages returned to Israel. When there are so few people in the nation, the loss of even 1 feels personal to everyone. The loss of so many and under such gruesome circumstances… horrendous.

But it doesn’t make the killing of 16,000 children ok.

Do human lives come down to numbers?

This isn’t a numbers game. But there comes a time when it is. The Irish know what it’s like when a colonising force initiates collective punishment. We know what it’s like to have brother turned against sister, parents against child, people turning to ever more dangerous acts to either escape or get food or just to do something.

The Black and Tans in Ireland were probably the best IRA recruiters of all time. And the current Israeli forces are probably the best campaigners for gaining sympathy for Palestine right now.

To the people who have lost family, friends, loved ones – it doesn’t matter whether they were one of 1200 or one of 50,000. The loss is the same to that person.

But to governments, to aid workers, to the rest of us – it has to matter.

Israel has better fire power, better funding, better weapons, better intelligence, better everything.

I keep getting told that if the IDF wanted to, they could have wiped out the whole of Palestine in a week after 7th October. And maybe they could. But they haven’t. They’ve gone for a slow, extended death of a people, rather than a surgical strike. There are reports of some truly inhumane thinking.

This approach has links to Trump’s calling immigrants “vermin” or worse. It has echoes of the Nazi approach to Jews in the 1930’s and 1940’s. it has definite shades of the British approach to Ireland – not just during the Great Famine, but throughout their occupation.

Some lives are worth more than others is the start of a very, very slippery slope to second class citizens and a very divided society.

And if you’re a Brigid follower – think of Brig Ambue.

Brigid’s Path: Know yourself!

The first step on Brigid’s Path is “Know Yourself”. People often as why? Well, we’re going to explore this in this post. And for those of you wondering if you’ve seen me writing on this before? Well yes, yes you have!

But first, I want to take you to last Friday night. I had a work night out and I really just wasn’t feeling it. I have been having fun in recent years with my make up. I’ve been experimenting with different eye shadows, different lip colours, just generally having fun. And it’s become part of my enjoyment of a night out.

But last Friday? Nope. Just… wasn’t….

And it took me a while to figure out why.

Picture of me, not being 100% happy with how I looked, but struggling with knowing myself enough to figure out why!
Yes this is me with the finished look from Friday night

What was going on?

Well, I didn’t like my foundation. You know when I figured this out? On the car drive home the following morning. Knowing yourself doesn’t always come with instant recognition.

But, I did figure it out and I knew something was wrong.

What didn’t I like? It was too watery. It felt like it was sitting on top of my skin rather than blending in. And – wonder of wonders for a 90’s woman – it was too pale…

(My former Goth-adjacent self is shuddering at that last sentence!)

But it’s all true. It just took me a while to figure out what was going on. I thought I was getting tired of my Il Makiage Woke Up Like This foundation – I hadn’t. I just needed to get a new bottle of it cos I’ve had that one for… (checks emails for last order)… more than 2 years. And even by my standards, that’s a while for a foundation to last. But a) I don’t wear make up that much and b) I kinda forget when I buy things, so I forget they need replacing before I use them all up!

If I didn’t know this about myself, I’d still be worrying about what was bothering me about that look. (And payday’s Thursday, my Il Makiage basket is ready for checkout!!)

Knowing myself in a broader sense

Now ok, ye don’t usually come to this blog for make-up tips. Or if you do, you’re going to be severely disappointed!!

When Brigid came to me first with the idea I had to get to know myself, I honestly didn’t know what she meant. Seriously. It didn’t make sense to be at all. Sure I had been living with myself for decades, my whole life even. How could I not know myself?

Well, I have an amazing skill in not knowing myself. For all sorts of reasons, I had turned not knowing myself into an art form. And a lot of us who grew up in the 80’s and 90’s are the same. Those “journeys of self-discovery” we saw coming from the States weren’t just pompous, entitled bullshit. They were damned necessary in many cases. (Albeit privileged in many ways!) Elizabeth Gilbert’s Eat, Pray, Love is the one that comes to mind. I’d love to be able to take that year long break that she did and head off to Italy, India and Bali (or, more likely in my case, places with lower temperatures and less spicy food…) For most of us, that option just isn’t available.

But you know what is available?

Tools and techniques

Yes. Now, in the Brigid’s Path Collective. we go through 4-6 weeks of this. So, there is a lot we cover and discuss and engage with. There are journaling questions, meditations, discussions… Lots goes on. But here’s a few things you can do yourself.

Google various quizzes. Here are a few of my favourite free or low(ish) cost quizzes:

https://www.16personalities.com/free-personality-test

https://psychcentral.com/quizzes/personality-quiz#1

https://www.truity.com/test/big-five-personality-test

https://www.authentichappiness.sas.upenn.edu/testcenter

https://www.discprofile.com/what-is-disc#:~:text=DiSC%20is%20an%20acronym%20that,on%20accomplishing%20bottom%2Dline%20results.

https://5voices.com

I’m not getting any income from these, they’re just personality quizzes I have found useful in my quest to understand myself better.

There are also a mountain of books I have found useful – this surprises no one, right? Ye know by now that my preferred means of absorbing information is a lovely comfy reading session.

The important thing is, you’re collecting information about yourself.

What to do with that information though?

Well, there are another 5 steps in the path, so don’t panic too much yet. But essentially, to understand what you need to progress down any path, you need to know where you are and what you need to survive.

For me, this involves my basic pillars of survival and thrival: food, water, movement, fresh air, sleep. If I get all of these in adequate quantities daily, life is good. And yes, this is all part of the information I had to figure out for myself. Seriously – the food part was so hard. If I can prevent even one more person in this world going down the eating disorder route… it’s not worth it, folks, and we all know better now, so let’s help the younger generations, yeah?

But why the first step?

For any journey to begin, you need to know where you are. That means acknowledging who you are, what you know and don’t know, what you want to learn, what you don’t want to know buy probably need to know anyway…

It means uncovering those shadowed areas of yourself and your soul. Looking in the mirror and determining if you like what you see, physically, emotionally and spiritually.

It means engaging with the times in your life you feel embarrassed and ashamed about. Examining your conscious about certain ongoing activities and see how you feel about it.

You don’t have to change anything just yet. But you do have to know how you feel about yourself. Your actions. Your behaviour.

No one said this would be easy

And it doesn’t always have to be difficult, either. There is plenty of both kinds of work involved in this journey.

But this is where you start.

Who are you?

What are you?

Where are you?

How did you get here?

What are the defining moments of your life to date?

What are the forces that shaped you?

What are you proud of? Not proud of?

Start asking yourself these questions. Spend some time with you and get to know yourself like you would a new friend. It’s worth it.

Know yourself

It’s been a while since I posted, and I’m sorry about that. But today, the message that’s coming to me is to help you get to know yourself. And looking at some questions to get to know yourself.

Seems a bit strange, right? After all, how could you not know yourself? You’ve been living with yourself for decades at this point! And it is a bit of a natural lead on from the last set of posts on getting to know Brigid. (Check out here, here and here for starters!)

But really, getting to know yourself, really know yourself, is a good first step on any spiritual path. Otherwise, you run the risk of straying from the path that suits you best, or possibly getting bound into something that’s wrong for you.

Where do I start?

Well, for me, I like to encourage people to start with a list of journaling prompts or questions to get to know yourself. If you google “questions to get to know yourself”, you will come up with millions of pages (ok, maybe a slight exaggeration) with lists of questions to get started. Here are ten of my favourites:

  • Who am I?
  • What am I?
  • What am I proud of?
  • What do I regret?
  • What am I really glad I finished, completed or achieved?
  • What am I worried about?
  • Who or what gives me comfort?
  • How can I show myself compassion?
  • What is my biggest short term goal?
  • What is my biggest long term goal?

I know. You’re looking at this right now and thinking “how in hell do I even start?”

A cartoon image of a figure with blonde hair, a hijabi with black hijab and green dress, dark hair with blue top, dark hair with yellow top and slightly less dark hair with blue top, all showing quizzical expressions and with question marks floating around their heads. How do you get to know yourself better?
How do you start getting to know yourself?
Seriously though, I don’t even know where to start with these questions.

Fair. It’s not easy at all. So here’s some help.

Make a ritual of it. Light a candle, do some meditation to start with, really ground and centre yourself. It’s easier not to go into this cold. Honestly, I’ve done this cold and it’s not worth my time.

But it can be really helpful to push yourself to make a real event for yourself here. Plan the occasion. Maybe have a sacred bath or shower beforehand. Dress comfortably. Engage with your favourite colour pen or fancy paper. Use a divination method to decide what questions to get to know yourself with!

Now, none of this is necessary. Of course, you can plop yourself down at your desk last minute and use whatever is to hand. That is always an option.

But if you are struggling to start with the questions, making a bit of ritual about it can help.

Ask Brigid

In life, we can forget about asking for help. I mean, I can’t guarantee she will appear in a flash of light, akin to what we think of when we think of the Madonna appearances. But she usually does respond to requests for help!

In a pinch, this can be a really simple, “I don’t know where to start, please help me!”

It can be a more complicated ritual all of its own. Depending on your relationship with Brigid, you will have different preferences and practices here and there’s nothing wrong with either approach. We tend to think that the Irish deities want us to be self-reliant, and they do! But they also will help us when needed.

Please, don’t worry about asking for help!

I feel like I know myself quite well

Brilliant. Then this exercise will be really easy for you! But I would argue that it’s still worthwhile.

Learning about ourselves is always valuable, in my opinion. And it’s possible, hell no, it’s probable that things will come up that are different. As people, we learn and grow throughout our lives. Your biggest regret may change over time – I know mine has! As I grow older, I find new regrets popping up all the time. And, old regrets just don’t seem that big a deal any more. Sometimes this is maturity. Sometimes it’s just the healing power of time.

We all know that life isn’t fair sometimes. And, we know that as we grow older, our outlooks change. If we are honest with ourselves, we can learn a lot about ourselves. I believe that this is a live long experience. Feel free to disagree! But it won’t change my mind about the exercise being valuable.

Are some questions better than others?

Well, here’s the thing. The best questions are those that you engage with. What suits your worldview? If you look at a list of questions, are there ones that you react strongly to? Being honest, if you are looking at a list of questions and you react either really positively or really negatively in your heart… probably a good idea to engage with that question.

But sometimes this is hard work. It sounds easy. Basically, you are sitting down and writing. Sure, what could be so difficult about that? Ye already know the answer here. In my practice, this is serious, worthwhile work. It’s not easy. Even just asking yourself to sit down with yourself and get to know yourself better… it’s hard.

So, go with your gut. Spend the time. Get to know yourself.

Then you can start tackling the really tough stuff!!